Goat's Milk Caramel Sauce

A big bowl of ice cream simply demands accoutrement. Let us introduce this rich and smooth caramel sauce made from goat’s milk. Handmade by Fat Toad Farm in Brookfield, Vermont. (more info)

Related Products
  • Cinnamon & Vanilla Glazed Pecans
  • Jack's Stir Brew Coffee Roast (Regular & Decaf)
  • Toad-farm-caramel
  • Open-uri20130816-17199-wz7luf
  • Open-uri20130816-17199-17lzkeu
  • Open-uri20130816-17199-uk4au4
  • Open-uri20130816-17199-zaydmp

I scream, you scream, we all scream for ice cream, right? But what does ice cream scream for? We think we've got the answer -- this no-nonsense goat's milk caramel sauce. It’s inspired by Mexican cajeta, a syrupy confection made with similar ingredients (sugar and goat’s milk), and it's for those who refuse to take dessert lightly (literally!). 

But don’t stop at ice cream. Make your Sunday pancakes extra luxe or add another layer of flavor to coffee.

The primary ingredients include goat’s milk, organic sugar, organic cornstarch, and baking soda. That's it. No high fructose corn syrup crapola like other caramels, so this one’s creamier and earthier – the way caramel should taste.

Available in four flavors: original, vanilla, cinnamon, and coffee. 

Use & Care

Listen to your inner six-year-old, and spoon over ice cream, drizzle on waffles, set out as a dip for fresh fruit, or, if you feel like being really bad, just eat it straight from the jar when nobody's looking.

A jar of unopened caramel will keep for a year in your cupboard, but you should refrigerate after opening. Separation is normal, so give it a quick stir before you use it. If it crystallizes, heat up slowly, and stir.

Production & Design

It all starts with happy goats that are milked twice daily. Next, organic sugar is dissolved into the goat's milk in a big copper pot. It bubbles away on the stove for about six hours while it's stirred constantly. After that, the caramel is poured into a jar that's hot water processed, labeled, and that's it.

Fat Toad Farm is a small, family-owned farm in Vermont. In 2007, it became a certified goat dairy.

Any Questions?

Please email  We reply to every email promptly. Or call us at 347 529 5122.

To stay updated on product launches and articles on our blog, follow us via , RSS, Twitter, FacebookGoogle+ or Pinterest.


8 fluid ounces (237 ml)

Goat’s milk, organic sugar, organic corn starch, baking soda

Made in
Brookfield, Vermont
  • USA
  • Free shipping in the USA for orders $75+ (UPS or USPS).
  • $8 UPS Ground/USPS Priority for orders $25 - $75.
  • $5 USPS First Class for orders under $25.
  • UPS 2nd Day $29.
  • 90 days on all unused items.
  • Free return shipping in the US.
  • NY & NC.
  • Kaufmann Mercantile has partnered with BorderFree to offer shipping around the world. During checkout BorderFree will estimate charges for shipping, customs, and duties as applicable depending on the destination for your order.
  • Click here to read our terms and conditions.



See New Products &
Read New Blog Articles


Get a $7 Gift Card
When You Sign Up

We will never share your information and you can unsubscribe at any time.

International Shipping

Kaufmann Mercantile now ships worldwide

Kaufmann Mercantile offers international shopping in your preferred currency –
even if it doesn't match the currency of your shipping destination. Your order total
is guaranteed at the exchange rate when your order is placed.

Borderfree is our global e-commerce partner. While Borderfree handles
your international order and transaction, Kaufmann Mercantile
directly handles all your customer service needs.

or ship to the U.S.